Purple prose is often seen as the bane of clear and effective writing. While vivid descriptions can enhance a story, overly ornate or flowery language risks alienating readers with its excess. Whether you’re a budding writer or a seasoned author, understanding how to recognize and avoid purple prose is key to creating engaging, concise work. In this article, we discuss what purple prose is, why it happens, and how to strike a balance between descriptive writing and overwriting.
What is Purple Prose? Defining Flowery and Overly Descriptive Writing
Purple prose refers to writing that is excessively ornate, verbose, or pretentious. This style often prioritizes elaborate descriptions, dense prose, and an overindulgent use of adjectives and metaphors over clarity and purpose. While vivid language has its place, purple prose can make sentences melodramatic and difficult to read.
Writers, particularly those new to the craft, may be tempted to use elaborate language to impress readers. However, it’s important to strike a balance between descriptive and concise writing. While purple prose can be captivating in small doses, it can quickly become tedious and distracting when overused.
- Example: Instead of writing, “The sky was painted with hues of orange, crimson, and violet, like a fiery symphony of colors competing for dominance,” a clearer version might say, “The sunset cast a warm orange and purple glow across the horizon.”
Why Does Purple Prose Happen?
Purple prose often arises when writers aim to impress readers with their vocabulary or style. It’s particularly common among new authors who equate flowery language with literary merit. The desire to sound poetic or sophisticated can result in overwritten sentences packed with overly descriptive passages and unnecessary metaphors.
One common pitfall is the excessive use of adjectives and adverbs. While these parts of speech can add depth and nuance to writing, they should be used judiciously. Overloading a sentence with modifiers can often obscure the intended meaning and create confusion.
How to Identify Purple Prose: Signs of Overwriting and Prolixity in Fiction
Recognizing purple prose in your work involves looking for key signs of overwriting. Here are some red flags to watch out for:
- Overuse of adjectives and ornate descriptions: A hallmark of purple prose is the excessive use of adjectives and flowery language. While adjectives add detail, too many can clutter your sentences and make them turgid. Similarly, overly descriptive writing risks losing the point of the narrative.
- Purple Prose: “The ancient, shadowy, and foreboding castle loomed ominously under the silver glow of the radiant moon, its towers piercing the heavens like silent sentinels.”
- Improved: “The old castle stood under the pale moonlight, its towers reaching into the sky.”
- Dense, overly complex sentences: Purple prose often manifests as unnecessarily elaborate sentences filled with excessive clauses. These sentences can be challenging to follow and lack impact. Prolixity in fiction often leads to readers losing track of the story or message.
- Purple Prose: “The cacophony of sounds, an amalgamation of chirping birds, rustling leaves, and distant echoes of life, converged upon the weary traveler as he trudged through the labyrinthine pathways of the ancient forest, each step a battle against the unseen forces of nature.”
- Improved: “Birds chirped, leaves rustled, and distant sounds echoed as the traveler moved through the winding forest paths.”
- Melodramatic and pretentious writing style: Writers trying too hard to sound profound often fall into the trap of melodramatic descriptions or pretentious writing styles. The result is writing that feels exaggerated and unnatural.
- Purple Prose: “Her tears cascaded like a torrential downpour, each drop a lament for the shattered fragments of her irreparable heart.”
- Improved: “She cried silently, her grief evident in her trembling shoulders.”
By simplifying your language and focusing on the story, you can avoid these pitfalls and ensure your writing remains clear and engaging.
How to Avoid Purple Prose: Achieving Balance Between Clarity and Style
If you struggle with overwriting, these tips will help you strike the right balance between description and clarity:
- Prioritize precision over excess: Instead of using ornate prose, aim for tight, clear sentences. Every word should serve a purpose. Ask yourself: Does this sentence move the story forward? If not, simplify or cut it. Replace dense prose with precise descriptions that convey meaning without excess. For example:
- Overwrought: “The wind howled with a ferocious intensity, battering against the windowpanes like a horde of angry spirits.”
- Concise: “The wind howled against the windows.”
- Avoid excessive metaphors and adjectives: Metaphors and adjectives add color to writing, but too many can overwhelm the reader. Focus on strong, purposeful descriptions rather than bombarding the reader with imagery.
- Overwrought: “Her dress shimmered like a thousand stars caught in the grip of midnight, dazzling all who dared to lay their eyes upon it.”
- Improved: “Her dress shimmered faintly under the light, drawing quiet admiration.”
- Write for clarity, not impressiveness: Readers appreciate clear prose that communicates effectively. Writing that feels overindulgent or verbose often detracts from the story. Avoid the temptation to showcase vocabulary for its own sake—overwriting doesn’t equal sophistication.
- Overwrought: “The sagacious professor expounded at tremendous length upon the esoteric implications of existential quandaries to the befuddled assembly of students.”
- Improved: “The professor explained complex existential ideas to his puzzled students.”
- Read your work aloud: Hearing your sentences can help identify turgid prose and awkward phrasing. If a sentence sounds unnecessarily long or ornate, simplify it. Good writing flows naturally and avoids feeling forced.
The Fine Line Between Vivid and Overwritten Prose
While rich descriptions are an essential part of storytelling, purple prose can overwhelm readers with its flowery language, excessive adjectives, and overly elaborate sentences. By focusing on clarity, purpose, and precision, you can achieve writing that is engaging without being overwrought. Keep your descriptions tight, avoid melodramatic or pretentious language, and remember: sometimes, less really is more.
When editing your work, be on the lookout for overwriting and prolixity. If a sentence feels too dense or ornate, simplify it to ensure your message shines through. Striking the right balance between vivid prose and clarity will elevate your writing while keeping readers immersed in the story.
Further Reading
It was a dark and stormy night on Wikipedia
Why does Faulkner get a pass for purple prose? on Stack Exchange
Lyrical Writing vs. Purple Prose by Cindy Baldwin, Thinking Through Our Fingers
In Defense of Purple Prose by Paul West, The New York Times